Movie Maker
Create a movie
English

Editor comparison

Which is better, Clipchamp or Movie Maker? A practical verdict

Which is better, Clipchamp or Movie Maker? For a new video, Clipchamp is usually the more practical choice: it is a current Microsoft editor, while Windows Movie Maker is discontinued. If you already have an old Movie Maker project, the immediate question is whether you can recover its original media and a finished export.

Explore video creation
Video creation imagery from Movie Maker

The answer at a glance

5 min read

Verdict first

These editors belong to different eras. The useful comparison is not which has the most familiar name, but which one fits the work you need to do now.

1

Clipchamp

Recommended

The better default for starting a new edit on a supported device.

In its favour

  • A current Microsoft editor rather than an unsupported legacy download.
  • Suited to assembling clips, adding text and audio, and producing a finished video.
  • Lets you begin with source media instead of relying on an old Movie Maker project file.

Against it

  • Does not open .wlmp files as editable timelines.
  • Its interface and workflow will be unfamiliar if you learned on Windows Movie Maker.
  • Features and export options should be checked in the version you use.

2

Windows Movie Maker

Useful mainly when you already have a working installation and an older project to finish.

In its favour

  • A familiar, straightforward timeline for people who used it before.
  • An existing installation may help you open a .wlmp project and export a viewing copy.
  • Can be used to identify which source files an older project still needs.

Against it

  • Microsoft discontinued it and no longer supports Windows Essentials.
  • Old projects depend on their original media files remaining available.
  • Searching for a new installer can expose you to misleading third-party downloads.

Dimension by dimension

The biggest differences concern support and project continuity. A rendered video may move between editors; the editable instructions behind that video generally do not.

1

Current status

Clipchamp

A current Microsoft video editor.

Windows Movie Maker

A discontinued Microsoft application formerly distributed with Windows Essentials.

2

Starting a new project

Clipchamp

Build an edit from imported video, images, and audio.

Windows Movie Maker

Possible if an old installation works, but it is not a sensible app to seek out for a new workflow.

3

Existing .wlmp project

Clipchamp

Cannot treat a .wlmp file as an editable Clipchamp timeline.

Windows Movie Maker

May open the project if the installed version works and its linked source files are present.

4

Source media

Clipchamp

Import the original files to rebuild an edit.

Windows Movie Maker

A project may refer to files at their old locations; moving them can leave media missing.

5

Finished video

Clipchamp

Can work with an exported video as a new source clip, but cannot restore its separate edits.

Windows Movie Maker

Can export a finished movie from a functioning project.

6

Interface

Clipchamp

A different editing workflow that requires some adjustment.

Windows Movie Maker

Familiar to people who already know the classic Movie Maker timeline.

7

Installation and support

Clipchamp

Use Microsoft's current distribution channels and check the requirements for your device.

Windows Movie Maker

Microsoft no longer provides support for Windows Essentials; avoid unverified installer sites.

8

Best use

Clipchamp

Create or revise a video from media you can access today.

Windows Movie Maker

Recover or finish an older project on a machine where it already runs.

Who each editor suits

Choose based on whether you are beginning, recovering, or rebuilding. That distinction matters more than trying to reproduce every control from the older editor.

When

You are making a video from clips you have now.

Then

Choose Clipchamp as the starting point.

You can organize the original media in a current editor without making a discontinued application part of your process. Make a short test edit first so you can check the tools and export choices available in your setup.

When

You have a .wlmp file and a computer where Movie Maker already works.

Then

Use that installation to inspect and preserve the old project.

Locate the referenced video, photo, and audio files before changing their folders. Export a finished copy if the timeline opens correctly, and keep the source files separately for any later rebuild.

When

You have only an exported movie, not the original clips.

Then

Treat the export as one video clip in a new edit.

You can trim or add material around a rendered movie, but its old titles, cuts, and audio mix will not reappear as independent timeline elements. Re-creating those details requires the original assets or manual work.

A sensible migration path

First preserve the .wlmp file and every source file it references. If Movie Maker still opens the project, export a viewing copy; then bring the original media into a current editor to make changes. An export is a reference, not an editable replacement for the old timeline.

Move forward with the media you have

Start with a video idea, not an obsolete installer

If your source clips are ready, explore Movie Maker's video-creation destination for a new project. Keep your original files and any legacy export together so you can compare the new result with the old one; check the destination's current capabilities before depending on a particular editing or import feature.

Explore video creation
  • Keep a copy of the original media.
  • Save a finished export of any recoverable old project.
  • Check current tool capabilities before rebuilding.

Comparison FAQ

For a new project, Clipchamp is usually the better choice because it is a current Microsoft editor and Windows Movie Maker is discontinued. A working Movie Maker installation can still be valuable for opening and exporting an older project, provided its source media is available.

Not as an editable .wlmp timeline. If you can still open the project in Movie Maker, export a finished video and preserve its original clips, photos, and audio; you can then use those files to build a new edit.

It is generally better to use a current editor. Microsoft ended support for Windows Essentials, and an unfamiliar site offering a Movie Maker installer should not be treated as an official source.

No. An export combines the visible edit into a finished video, so another editor sees it as media rather than the original arrangement of clips, titles, and effects. Keep the project file and original assets if you might need to reconstruct the timeline.

Look for the original video, image, and audio files in backups or folders from the computer where the project was made. A .wlmp file can retain references to those files without containing the files themselves; finding them is more useful than switching editors immediately.

Create a movie
Create a movie